moto Juan method Ksharp nicKn0iT Volcano ComeBackDan Dark Storm Coolsvilla Cheppelle WiZaKoR
NextGen Servers
 

May 8, 2008 at 09:24 PM CDT

View Comments: 21

Sandbagging, A Necessary Evil?

Posted by: toast


sand·bag [sand-bag·ging]
practice of purposely placing oneself in a weaker position so as to give the deceptive impression that one is less skilled than one truly is..

Kansas City, MO

Name:
Jon Corley

Position:
Writer

About The Author
Jon Corley is a failed professional gamer who currently heads 3D.NY's Website Staff

It seems a new fad is sweeping the CGS by storm, no it's not bell-bottoms or pet rocks, rather it is sandbagging! What is sandbagging you might ask, well it's just as silly as the term used to describe it! Simply put, sandbagging is throwing matches in order to make your opponent look better. The term originated from poker slang, and is described as the act of playing your strong hand as weak in order to lure opponents into betting into a pot which they cannot win. In case you haven't figured out, I'm adamant about sportsmanship and am pretty disappointed over the matches being thrown or "sandbagged" if you prefer that term.

However, I'm not an unreasonable man and I entirely understand the strategy and reasoning behind this practice, but that doesn't make it the right thing to do. Sandbagging in poker is good practice and by not doing so you are asking to lose money. However, sandbagging in the CGS is a whole different animal. By participating in this practice, GM's are not only toying with the emotions of their taxi players, but also with those of their fans. I for one am an advocate for believing that the fans deserve better treatment than this. CGS should not have to offer prize money in order to get franchises to play at their peak ability, they should naturally want to do well and try their damnedest. Not only is this disappointing as a viewer, I also think that it is potentially damaging to people who were already on the fence about the CGS. Why bother to watch a match if it is just two players who are mindlessly mashing buttons in order to get it over with.

Also, this seemingly senseless substitution of taxi players at times is getting out of hand. In theory, it seemed like an excellent idea, allow the GM's to try out their newly drafted players and if necessary call up a proven performer who got passed on in the draft. However, it is being exploited as nothing more than another way to sandbag by benching an obvious Season 2 starter and substituting in a taxi player who has no chance of making the final roster. Again, let me reiterate, I am not an unreasonable man. I can understand if someone needs to take a week off or GM's want to try out a new combination, but when teams superstars are being benched week in and week out, it is not only damaging the teams reputation, it is an act of poor sportsmanship.

Not only does sandbagging reduce the pre-season to nothing more than a necessity, it also doesn't give the fans a good representation of what they're seeing. Like any television show, CGS exists to please viewers and expand their audience. That being said, they should treat the pre-season as a means to attract new viewers and keep last season’s viewers interested and excited for Season 2. Although it is virtually impossible to determine when sandbagging is occurring and when it is not, there exist several relatively simple solutions to alleviate this quandary.

I can accept failure. Everyone fails at something. But I can’t accept not trying - Michael Jordan

One recommendation of mine would be to make the preseason play a bigger role than it does. Currently it is being used as a tune-up of sorts for the franchises and let’s face it, they aren't taking it all that serious. CGS shouldn’t have to throw more money at these guys to make them play their hardest, they can motivate them in other more abstract ways. One suggestion of mine would be to make the preseason final placing the draft order for say Round 3 of next year’s draft. This would not only make teams play their hardest in hopes of improving their draft order, it would also punish those squads who think it necessary to sandbag. Another such suggestion would be to let teams who place well in the preseason select game order for their matches, picking which divisions play in which order. However, both these suggestions rely on the concept that GM’s would be doing their best to win the preseason, thus making taxi players all the more irrelevant than they already are. It is a double edged sword, by making the preseason count for something, you are making it nearly impossible for a GM to bench a player, only in the most dire of situations would a taxi player be called up.

All things considered, I consider sandbagging to be a poor show of sportsmanship by those who indulge themselves in this practice and thank those players who have played to the best of their ability during the first 3 weeks of the preseason. There is no easy solution, and maybe nothing is wrong with the preseason as it is and I’m just ranting, but nonetheless I’d love to hear other people’s thoughts and suggestions on the matter.


  Digg This Digg This Stumble Upon Stumble This Digg This Post to Del.icio.us

#1

May 9, 2008 at 12:01 AM CDT

theultimategamer
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 737
Location: jasper

good read.



first official, newoptimeranomplexina fan.
http://www.myspace.com/earllovings31

#2

May 9, 2008 at 12:14 AM CDT

DchozN
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 1175
Location: Chicago

Staff Member Staff Member

Jon Corley is a failed professional gamer who currently heads 3D.NY's Website Staff.

#3

May 9, 2008 at 12:44 AM CDT

moto
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 1108
Location: Austin

Team GM Team GM

Referenced post #2 by DchozN
Jon Corley is a failed professional gamer who currently heads 3D.NY's Website Staff.
#2 I laughed out loud when i read that.

#4

May 9, 2008 at 01:28 AM CDT

OpTiMuSNY
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 447
Location: Bronx

Staff Member Staff Member

haha jon cool description.

#5

May 9, 2008 at 01:54 AM CDT

iCam
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 717
Location: Prospect

Pro Gamer Pro Gamer

so why is there a pic of singapore and korea as the header?? good read

myspace.com/llxcamxll


#6

May 9, 2008 at 01:57 AM CDT

toast
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 308
Location: MIZZOU

Staff Member Staff Member

insert random banner picture

#7

May 9, 2008 at 01:57 AM CDT

MarkDolven
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 1055
Location: Carolina

Team GM Team GM

The answer to the title of this article is yes.

Mark Dolven
General Manager
http://www.CarolinaCore.com

#8

May 9, 2008 at 02:11 AM CDT

NITRO
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 4093
Location: Sydney

Staff Member Staff Member

Interesting ....

Reg Torr - Forum & IRC Moderator
[RAK] Random Acts of Kindness. Do your part!

3D Fan since 2003

#9

May 9, 2008 at 02:23 AM CDT

toKs1c
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 381
Location: Eden Prairie

I am a failed pro gamer, hire this kid

"Even the biggest noob can tell RL from a game. This is like DX5000 graphics...."

#10

May 9, 2008 at 03:08 AM CDT

r0ck-leet
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 13
Location:

i disagree

preseason doesn't really mean anything in all sports, and that's what i expect the preseason to be; an exhibition. Name a sport or anything to do with preseason and tell me they play with their hearts out. Even preseason in CAL or CEVO; no one really cares. I don't think it reflects poor sportsmanship. It's basically to get the teams ready and shake off the rust of the format of play.

Even with that quote of jordan, im sure he doesn't try in his exhibition games or even play

It doesn't give a good representation of what the fans are seeing, but the fans know that these games have no meaning (so its expected). I also think its awesome us fans get to see some taxi players play, even thought its only preseason. It makes it seem like they are more part of the team.

Last modified on 5/9/2008 at 3:08 am EST

#11

May 9, 2008 at 03:19 AM CDT

toast
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 308
Location: MIZZOU

Staff Member Staff Member

The preseason in every sport on the professional level means the world to the players on the brink of success, They relish every opportunity to strut their stuff and show that they deserve to be on the final roster and CGS should be no different. The idea of the taxi system is so that players who didn't get drafted can practice and improve and eventually show once and for all that they are deserving of a starting spot, just like in any other sport. I'd much rather see the taxi players play each other than the starters just jack around for 5 weeks.

Last modified on 5/9/2008 at 3:20 am EST

#12

May 9, 2008 at 03:39 AM CDT

r0ck-leet
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 13
Location:

so what u want them to do?

put in their taxi players in and if they do good, bench their starters? The players they want have been picked and the ones trying to show they belong had a whole year to get drafted. Plus this is online preseason matches.

to me, this is exactly like pro sports. I'm sure the ones that got newly drafted are proud to strut their stuff wearing their new tags (like juan and noit). The veteran players would probably not have that same feeling as them; like say a ladainian tomlinson of the NFL (who sits out during preseasons). I'm not sure about the stats on how preseason and regular seasons correlates in pro sports; but they usually aren't a key indicator of how well a team does in the season.

#13

May 9, 2008 at 03:56 AM CDT

DocsFox
shieldshieldshieldshield
Posts: 37
Location:

Try hard, or go home.

#14

May 9, 2008 at 08:34 AM CDT

jlake02
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 2260
Location: Atlanta

Team GM Team GM

Really good article, and great quote to use.

Join the RAK movement!
http://lacomplexity.thecgs.com/Random_Acts_of_Kindness_-_2008

#15

May 9, 2008 at 11:35 AM CDT

mytronphe
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 152
Location: Uden

Referenced post #2 by DchozN
Jon Corley is a failed professional gamer who currently heads 3D.NY's Website Staff.
#2
lol

Good read anyway!
IMO The taxi players should be trained / tested in the pre-season..
"There is no love in an abandoned steel mill"

#16

May 9, 2008 at 12:06 PM CDT

Ne0phyt3
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 1354
Location: Rotterdam, The Netherlands

Agreeing with the good article here

http://lacomplexity.thecgs.com/Random_Acts_of_Kindness_-_2008
http://www.myspace.com/arjen_b

#17

May 9, 2008 at 12:17 PM CDT

gen0cide
shieldshieldshieldshield
Posts: 9
Location:

Great article, Jon. I couldn't agree more.

#18

May 9, 2008 at 01:00 PM CDT

AlbeL
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 5365
Location: Outside Belfast

Staff Member Staff Member

ITS TOAST TIME

"Competitions can help us uncover our weaknesses...and discover we are our own true enemy."

#19

May 9, 2008 at 06:22 PM CDT

c0k3zorz
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 861
Location: westcovina

very interesting...

:D

#20

May 10, 2008 at 07:04 PM CDT

bond^
shieldshieldshieldshield

Posts: 26
Location: Long Island

good read!

Small minds, small lives.

#21

May 12, 2008 at 09:23 AM CDT

Essent1al
shieldshieldshieldshield
Posts: 1
Location:

Just like in any other sport, there will be teams that will participate in such actions. There's really nothing that can be done short of making pre-season (Like Jon said) MATTER alot more to the point that the Taxi player's do not get a chance to show what they got.

You just have to sit back and hope that the team you support would be consciensous of it's fan's and consciensous that it's costing the CGS fans, and in turn MONEY. If the CGS loses viewers, fans, and money, it wont exist for much longer, and the prize purse the teams played so dirtily to win will no longer exist due to their own actions.

CGS has put professional gaming to the test. Will the fan's be loyal enough to watch a mockery of a 5-week waste of time and still stick around to watch when it matters? Probably not. To any GM's who have read this article and may in fact read this post, it is in the best interest of pro gaming, and of the CGS for you to discontinue sandbagging, the saying goes, play hard go pro, In that motto I don't hear any rendition of "Sandbagging". Give us what we want.
Goto Page 1 or Jump to
 

Do you have GTA 4?


No
Yes

 
NextGen Servers Skyscraper